ASN logo
ASN Wikibase Occurrence # 18939
Last updated: 30 August 2020
This information is added by users of ASN. Neither ASN nor the Flight Safety Foundation are responsible for the completeness or correctness of this information. If you feel this information is incomplete or incorrect, you can submit corrected information.

Date:15-SEP-1993
Time:14:18 LT
Type:Silhouette image of generic P28A model; specific model in this crash may look slightly different
Piper PA-28-161 Cherokee Warrior II
Owner/operator:British Aerospace Flying College
Registration: G-BNOD
C/n / msn: 2816012
Fatalities:Fatalities: 1 / Occupants: 1
Other fatalities:0
Aircraft damage: Written off (damaged beyond repair)
Location:Wham Rig Hill, 5 miles W of Sanquhar, Dumfries & Galloway -   United Kingdom
Phase: En route
Nature:Training
Departure airport:Prestwick Airport (PIK/EGPK)
Destination airport:Prestwick Airport (PIK/EGPK)
Narrative:
Struck high ground at Wham Rig Hill, Glenglass, five miles west of Sanquhar, Dumfries & Galloway on 15-9-1993 (at approximate Coordinates: 5522′05″N 355′29″W) following a PAN call 'aircraft entering cloud'. Aircraft destroyed, student trainee pilot (flying on a solo navigational exercise) was killed.

In February 2002, the family of the pilot initiated a legal claim for 400,000 in compensation for their loss. According to a contemporary report in the Daily Mirror:

"Parents blame flying college over son's death

A YOUNG trainee pilot made a promise to his parents that he would support them in their old age and pay for the education of his two younger brothers. The promise, based on religion and close family ties, was one that Tareq Shaher was never able to keep because, a few weeks later, he died after losing his bearings in cloud and crashing his plane into a Scottish hillside during a solo training flight.

Now Mr Shaher's family is claiming damages of 400,000 from the flying college where their son was training when he smashed into Wham Rig Hill, five miles west of Sanquhar in Dumfriesshire, in September, 1993.

The action at the Court of Session is being pursued by his father, Mohammed Shaher, his mother Fayza, and his brother Talal, who live in Bahrain. The family claims that ''boisterous and immature'' Mr Shaher, then 19, was unsuitable for continued flying training and that the British Aerospace Flying College at Prestwick was negligent in letting him keep flying.

The flying school denies liability and describes Mr Shaher as capable and intelligent trainee with the potential to become a good pilot. The college maintains, however, that Mr Shaher was to blame for his own death because he failed to follow instructions and flew into cloud.

Mr Shaher was training for a commercial pilot's licence under the sponsorship of Gulf Air. On September 15, he had been briefed to fly a Piper Warrior on a cross-country exercise. He had 89 hours flying time, more than 43 of them solo. He had flown solo for the first time the previous May and had passed two progress tests.

He took off from Prestwick about 2.20pm and an hour later reported to Scottish air traffic control that he was in cloud. He is believed to have become disorientated and at 4.49pm the wreckage of his aircraft was found at Wham Rig Hill. He died from multiple injuries.

His family alleges that the flying school knew that Mr Shaher had shown indiscipline and erratic behaviour and should have stopped his training after, at the latest, 40 hours. The college says that Mr Shaher had been warned that if he encountered cloud he should turn his plane round and retrace the route he had often flown before. The cloud was visible from at least 15km and could readily have been avoided, but the pilot failed to follow his instructions. At the point of the crash, he was also 15 nautical miles off track.

Mohammed Shaher, 61, a retired senior manager with Gulf Air, told the court yesterday that Bahrain was a Muslim country where families kept to traditions and religious teachings. ''He knew his brothers were going to have private educations and he promised that he would shoulder the cost of their education. He made that promise to me and his mother. This is normal because a member of the family has an obligation to support the other members of his family.''

Mr Shaher added: ''In our religion, we have an obligation to support needy members of our family. Tareq, by his religion, was required to help his brothers in their education and his mother and father in old age and to provide them with the same standard of living that they have been enjoying.''

The hearing before Lord Wheatley continues and is expected to last eight days."

On 28-5-2002, it was announced that the legal claim for compensation was partially successful: the family of the pilot were awarded 41,228 Damages (just over one tenth of what was claimed)(See link #5)

Damage sustained to airframe: Per the AAIB report "Aircraft destroyed". As a result, the registration G-BNOD was cancelled by the CAA as aircraft "destroyed" on 29-11-1993

Sources:

1. AAIB: https://assets.digital.cabinet-office.gov.uk/media/5422ff56ed915d1371000a17/Piper_PA-28-161_Cherokee_Warrior_II__G-BNOD_01-94.pdf
2. CAA: https://siteapps.caa.co.uk/g-info/rk=BNOD
3. http://www.heraldscotland.com/news/12138541.Parents_blame_flying_college_over_son_apos_s_death/
4. https://www.scotsman.com/news/crash-pilot-erratic-say-parents-1-604696
5. http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/uk_news/scotland/2012636.stm


Images:

Photo of G-BNOD courtesy AirHistory.net


Leuchars (EGQL / ADX)
September 1988; (c) David Unsworth

Revision history:

Date/timeContributorUpdates
17-May-2008 11:10 ASN archive Added
14-Sep-2012 18:06 Dr. John Smith Updated [Time, Registration, Cn, Operator, Location, Phase, Nature, Departure airport, Source, Damage, Narrative]
20-May-2016 19:02 Dr.John Smith Updated [Aircraft type, Location, Departure airport, Source, Narrative]
20-May-2016 19:03 Dr.John Smith Updated [Destination airport]
20-May-2016 19:09 Dr.John Smith Updated [Source, Narrative]

Corrections or additions? ... Edit this accident description